In partnership with

Hello and welcome to the 212th edition of Fresh Salmon.

If you're new here - welcome aboard.
And if you’d like to catch up on past issues, you can explore the archive anytime.

Meet our primary partner for today’s edition: Agentic Marketing Summit. Check them out 👇

The era of manual marketing ends this May!

Manual marketing had a good run.

But the teams winning right now aren't briefing, approving, and repeating. They're directing AI agents that execute the whole strategy for them.

The Agentic Marketing Summit (May 4–8) is a free, five-day event that shows you exactly how it works in practice. Not theory. Not a PDF checklist. Step-by-step insight to help you become an expert in AI marketing agents.

Hosted by 3x Inc 5000 founder Manick Bhan alongside the sharpest minds in the marketing world today.

The era of doing it yourself is over!

Join Free Today!

The Two Lies B2B Marketers Keep Falling For

Why "build a community" and "AI will kill newsletters" are the same scam wearing different outfits.

There's a pattern in B2B marketing advice right now that should make you suspicious.

The same people telling you email is dying are also selling you the replacement. The same analysts warning that AI will gut your newsletter are quietly building the AI tool that does the gutting. The same founders who raised millions to build "professional communities" are now writing essays about why communities are the future of B2B distribution.

Notice anything?

Every prediction about the death of email comes from someone with a product to sell you on the way down.

And B2B marketers who should know better, because we invented the playbook of manufactured urgency - are falling for it.

Let's look at the two lies in detail.

Meet our secondary partner for today’s edition: BELAY. Check them out 👇

When Pressure Rises, Here’s Where Leaders Turn

Costs rise. Clients delay. Pressure builds.

The Survival Hub gives you practical ways to respond from cutting costs to tightening operations and staying on top of revenue.

Built to help you take control when things feel uncertain.

Visit BELAY’s Survival Hub

Lie #1: "Build a community."

This is the most expensive bad advice in B2B right now.

Communities are pitched as the ultimate moat. Owned audience. Direct relationships. Network effects. The deck practically writes itself.

And the logic sounds right: if your audience is talking to each other, not just to you, you've built something durable.

There's just one problem. Communities have a negative network effect.

The reality is - a community of 50 engaged operators is electric. A community of 5,000 is a Slack channel where people mute notifications and forget the password. The bigger it gets, the lower the signal, the faster the early members leave, and the more it starts to feel like LinkedIn with a paywall. Discord servers know this. Slack groups know this. Every "exclusive" Circle community that turned into a graveyard knows this.

The dirty secret is that the only communities that do work in B2B are tiny, expensive, and curated by hand - masterminds, peer groups, executive forums. None of those scale. None of those are what's being sold to you when someone says "build a community."

What's being sold is the aesthetic of community. The dashboard. The member count. The illusion of a moat.

Meanwhile, the channel that actually delivers - email - gets dismissed as old-fashioned.

Meet our secondary partner for today’s edition: Mintlify. Check them out 👇

Are you tracking agent views on your docs?

AI agents already outnumber human visitors to your docs — now you can track them.

See your AI traffic!

Lie #2: "AI will kill newsletters."

This one is more sophisticated because it sounds technical.

Gemini summarizes emails inside Gmail. Superhuman filters out marketing automatically. Apple Mail obscures your open rates. The argument goes: soon, AI will read your newsletter for your subscriber, hand them a three-bullet summary, and your carefully crafted prose will rot unread in a folder no human ever opens.

Here's what this argument gets wrong.

AI is not a threat to good newsletters. AI is a threat to bad newsletters. And B2B is drowning in bad newsletters.

What AI cannot replicate, and what it will never replicate, is the thing readers actually subscribe for: a specific human with a specific point of view, drawing on specific experience, willing to be wrong in public. The operator who ran the campaign and tells you why it failed. The founder who saw the trend two quarters before the analysts. The marketer who calls a specific tactic stupid and explains why with receipts.

A summary cannot have taste. A digest cannot have a grudge.

The newsletters that die in the AI era will be the ones that should have died in 2019. The ones that survive will be the ones with a human attached to them - opinionated, experienced, occasionally annoying, recognizably real.

The connection nobody is making

Here's the part that should bother you.

The "build a community" pitch and the "AI will kill email" pitch are both arguments to abandon the channel that works for you and adopt the channel that works for the person selling you advice.

Substack says email is unreliable, and recommends posting on Substack Notes. Community platforms say email is dead, and recommend their app. AI tooling companies say AI will summarize your emails, and sell you AI tooling.

This is not analysis. This is a sales funnel disguised as a thought leadership post.

The boring truth, which nobody can monetize a course around, is this: email still works. It works better than communities, better than SMS, better than push, and significantly better than any social platform you don't own. It works because it's the only channel where you control the list, the content, the timing, and the relationship.

The reason your newsletter isn't growing isn't the channel. The channel is fine. The channel is, in fact, the most resilient distribution asset in B2B.

The reason your newsletter isn't growing is that you're publishing the kind of content AI can replace, while being told the solution is to build a community AI hasn't figured out how to ruin yet.

Fix the content. Keep the channel. Ignore anyone who tells you otherwise, especially if they have a product page.

That’s it for this week.

If this edition sparked an idea for you, share it with someone building in B2B.

See you next time.

Do what is good for your soul ❤️

Vivek